Cactus vs. IntellCRE: Comparing Underwriting Software

Commercial real estate underwriting has entered a new era. AI-powered solutions are replacing outdated manual processes, driving faster analysis, greater accuracy, and better investment decisions. Two major players in this transformation are Cactus and IntellCRE. Both platforms promise automation, efficiency, and smarter deal analysis—but which one delivers superior results? Let's break down the key differences.

1. Speed: How Quickly Can You Underwrite?

Cactus: Underwriting in Minutes

Cactus eliminates manual data entry, extracting key financials from rent rolls, operating statements, and T12s in under five minutes. Automated calculations mean underwriting models update instantly as variables change, allowing investors to analyze five times more deals in the same timeframe.

IntellCRE: Slower, More Manual Input Required

IntellCRE offers automation but still relies on significant manual input. Users often spend 30-60 minutes per deal adjusting assumptions, verifying data, and troubleshooting formatting issues. This slows down decision-making and reduces deal flow efficiency.

2. Accuracy: Reducing Human Error and Standardizing Models

Cactus: AI-Driven Accuracy (30% Fewer Errors)

Cactus automatically validates financial inputs, flags discrepancies, and suggests adjustments. AI cross-checks numbers across all uploaded documents, eliminating formula errors and reducing underwriting inaccuracies by 30%.

IntellCRE: Prone to User Error

IntellCRE still requires extensive spreadsheet-style manipulation. While it provides basic automation, errors creep in when users manually adjust formulas. Inconsistent modeling across teams can lead to discrepancies in deal evaluations.

3. Market Data Integration: Real-Time Insights vs. Stale Assumptions

Cactus: Built-In Real-Time Market Data

Cactus pulls live market data, including cap rates, rent comps, and expense benchmarks. Users don't have to rely solely on broker reports—Cactus ensures valuations align with current market conditions.

IntellCRE: Limited Market Data

IntellCRE relies on user-uploaded data, meaning the accuracy of underwriting depends on external sources and manual input. Without automatic market updates, users risk basing decisions on outdated assumptions.

4. Debt & Equity Modeling: Flexibility and Scenario Testing

Cactus: Instant Scenario Testing

Cactus allows users to run multiple financing scenarios, instantly adjusting debt service coverage ratios (DSCR), loan-to-value (LTV) ratios, and cap rates. Investors can tweak assumptions in real-time to assess deal feasibility.

IntellCRE: Rigid Financing Models

IntellCRE requires manual adjustments for each scenario, making sensitivity analysis time-consuming and cumbersome. Users must rework spreadsheets for every variable change, slowing down decision-making.

5. Collaboration & Workflow Efficiency

Cactus: Seamless Team Collaboration

Cactus is cloud-based, ensuring all team members work from a single source of truth. Version control issues disappear, and deal approvals become faster. Investors, lenders, and brokers can collaborate effortlessly.

IntellCRE: Siloed, Spreadsheet-Based Approach

IntellCRE underwriting models are often exported into spreadsheets for sharing, leading to version conflicts and lost data. Teams waste valuable time reconciling different versions of the same underwriting model.

6. Pricing & ROI: Which Offers Better Value?

Cactus: High ROI at a Flat Fee

For $175 per month, Cactus delivers unlimited underwriting, built-in market data, and AI-powered accuracy. The platform pays for itself with a single deal, given the time saved and improved deal flow.

IntellCRE: Higher Costs, Less Automation

IntellCRE pricing varies based on feature selection but often exceeds $300 per user per month. With more manual work required, the return on investment is lower, and deal throughput remains constrained.

Final Verdict: Cactus Delivers Faster, Smarter Underwriting

Cactus outperforms IntellCRE in speed, accuracy, automation, and cost-efficiency. Investors using Cactus analyze 5x more deals, eliminate error-prone spreadsheets, and make faster, data-driven decisions.

Ready to leave outdated underwriting behind? Schedule a demo today and see why industry leaders choose Cactus over IntellCRE every time.

‍